跳至內容開始

Project Evaluation

Community-Based Professional Intervention Programs - Outcome Evaluation

Community-Based Professional Intervention Programs - Group Activities

As of April 2023, the four collaborating NGOs have organized a total of 151 family group activities. Each group activity is attended by both parents and their children, with a total of 2,100 participants from 860 families. The intervention methods included the "Family Adventure Training", "Family Art Experience", "Family Photo Album" and "Family Mindfulness". The Project Research has utilized different methods to evaluate the program effectiveness. 

Overview of Activity Implementation

The subjective outcome evaluation showed that group activities benefited the participants in several aspects: gains in knowledge, attitude, behavior, and condition. For example, 96% of the participants agreed that the program helped them to understand how to coordinate with each other in the family and face adversity together. It also made them believed that family members could support each other to overcome difficulties. In terms of attitude changes, most participants expressed that the programs enhanced their confidence to face adversity and reduced their sense of helplessness caused by adversity. In terms of behavioural changes, the programs strengthened the mutual support and positive communication among family members. 

One-group pretest-posttest evaluation showed that after completing the program, participants experienced a significant decrease in overall negative emotions (stress, anxiety, and depression), with a significant increase in their level of  family resilience and life satisfaction. 

單組前後測評估 1
單組前後測評估 2
單組前後測評估 3
單組前後測評估 4

Single group pre- and post-test analysis

Note: p < 0.001 (Two-tailed Test)

The results of quasi-experimental analysis (304 participants in the experimental group and 166 in the control group) showed that the overall negative emotions, anxiety, and depression of the participants in the experimental group significantly reduced, as compared with those in the control group. In contrast, their level of family resilience and marital satisfaction increased significantly. Different evaluation methods showed that our intervention programs were effective in improving the mental health of families and providing them with protective factors against family adversities. 

Objective Outcome Evaluation 1

Objective Outcome Evaluation 2

Objective Outcome Evaluation 3
Objective Outcome Evaluation 4
Objective Outcome Evaluation 5
Objective Outcome Evaluation 6
Objective Outcome Evaluation 7
Note: The control group refers to families that have not participate in the programs.
The experimental group refers to families that participated in the programs.

Community-Based Professional Intervention – Piecemeal Programs 

From March 2022 to February 2023, the four NGOs had organized a total of 277 sessions of educational activities in various communities and attracted as many as 6,200 participants. The activities included lectures, trips, workshops, day camps and exhibitions. The subjective outcome evaluation showed that participants had a high level of positive comments on those activities. On the questionnaire with rating scale from 1 to 6 (the higher the score, the higher the satisfaction level), the average score for each item exceeded 5, which 95% of them indicated their positive comments, as summarised below: 
 
Knowledge Effectiveness 1: concept of family resilience Average score Percentage of positive comment
Knowledge Effectiveness 2: discovery of family merits and drawbacks 5.07 95%
Knowledge Effectiveness 2: discovery of family merits and drawbacks 5.05 95%
Attitude Effectiveness (e.g.: participants have more positive belief toward family) 5.09 96%
Effectiveness in state 5.00 95%
Effectiveness in behaviour 5.07 96%
Comments on staff 5.38 98%
Comments on activities 5.33 98%
Satisfaction on activities 5.38 98%